Saturday, 9 August 2014


Highlights of an NHS Week - 8th August

So Jerry’s away, what can we do with his blog?!?!  Sharons Matson and Williams have been entrusted with this precious item!


We have been left with a clear set of instructions – clear that is, if you understand blog terminology and Twitter.  Jerry’s parting message was “Enjoy, and babysit well!”  In other words, don’t mess it up!!! 


We have seen a few photos of JC and the family; they seem to be having a good time.  Holiday reading material however seems of questionable quality and taste.  Hilariously we have also seen some photos of the Clough’s dog being “looked after” by neighbours and a promise to only return him if Ouzo is brought back!





So when looking after a blog, one finds oneself really reflecting on what’s gone on in the week.  What is worthy of publishing?  What is worthy of tweeting?  At some point, panic sets in that there will be nothing worth sharing.  However, the panic eventually subsides and some moments of brilliant experience emerge.  Here are this week’s.


Highlights of the Week 1 – Co-ordinating a response for national funding


The Western Locality are co-ordinating the CCG’s contribution to schemes to be funded by a national challenge fund.  As is often the case, the rules are prescriptive, the time-scales terribly short and clashing with summer holidays when many people that need to contribute are themselves, on holiday.  Trying to co-ordinate a series of proposals across 124 practices, ensuring that the schemes they put forward demonstrate value for money and will deliver the programme’s ambitions and objectives is a challenge but this week, we have the real sense that we will extend patient access to primary care and genuinely test some new models of care over the next six months.


Highlights of the Week 2 – The complexity of the urgent care system


Our Urgent Care Partnership met this week.  The agenda was full – Better Care Fund, performance and service demands, delayed transfers of care, learning from Operation Springback and a discussion about our Strategic Resilience Planning were just some of the key items for discussion by senior personnel from a range of organisations.  We had some fantastic challenge and input from our secondary and primary care clinicians and wider members of our community.  We have committed to really “test” our resilience plan so that we can demonstrate a real sense of confidence in the plan that will underpin the “winter” period and we agreed to really focus on ensuring that patients receive high quality services in care in the right setting, at the right time, rather than experiencing preventable delays.  The meeting overran slightly but it was worth it for the thought-provoking debate.


Highlights of the Week 3 – Facebook – some elements of brilliance


Anyone who has a Facebook account will be used to seeing photos, jokes, news feeds and random adverts popping up on their timeline.  This week, this appeared on mine:


Description: C:\Users\matsons\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\WCD5LR1G\photo.JPG


This made me pause and think; think how often people genuinely stop, listen and think.  In the Western locality, we have been using Nancy Klein’s wonderful “Thinking Environment” for over a year now.  Personally, I find that using some of the techniques, active listening, rounds and incisive questions, hugely calming and they generate a sense of peacefulness for me.  On a number of occasions, in a large meeting with a complex agenda, where there is a risk of some people not being heard or certain people dominating the conversation, I request that we use the thinking environment to steady the level of noise, the risk of conversations crashing into each other and ensuring that everyone gets a chance to speak and that we get the most out of our expensive and increasingly precious time.  


We’ve been using the Thinking Environment with our wider Locality teams and stakeholders at our Big Events; the third of which was held a few weeks ago.  This week, I wrote up the product of the Big Listen from a few weeks ago where people tell the Senior Leadership Team what’s important to them and the SLT really, really listen to what is said (without hesitation, repetition or duplication!).  There are some real strengths in what’s happening in both the Locality and the wider CCG.  Some of the feedback is set out below:

Description: C:\Users\matsons\AppData\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\WCD5LR1G\wordcloud Q2.png




Highlights of the Week 4 –   Simon Stevens visits Devon


Simon Stevens NHS England's CEO made his inaugural visit to Devon this week.  He was visiting Dartmouth Hospital to listen to local voluntary organisations and to see local community services in action.


In a county that already subscribes to the value of using community services, resources and assets recently set out at the NHS confederation conference, it was great for local leaders of health and social care organisations to have the opportunity  to talk about the wider health needs of the local population and the challenges at hand. 


Dr Tim Burke, NEW Devon's Chair was delighted to meet with Simon Stevens and glad to see local voluntary sector organisations receiving the recognition they deserve.  They provide such a significant part in supporting local communities across Devon and we have high expectations that this will only increase as the joint strategy signed up to across the health economy moves from plan to implementation.



Highlights of the Week 5 –  Strong partnerships in action

Since March, the demand for emergency care services has risen by about 10%.  We are not alone, the rest of the country is also reporting increases in demand but what makes us slightly different in Devon is that we introduced NHS 111 in March.  The natural assumption is, not unreasonably, that the cause must be 111.  It isn't - if only life were that simple!


All organisations in Devon have worked really hard to get to the root cause of the demand increase - none more so than the service provider themselves.  Their performance is amongst, if not, the best in the country; 95% of patients surveyed would use the service again; the evidence reviewed today at a summit chaired by the CCG shows that the cause is not 111 but is a combination of many facets in our health and care system.  


The debate in the room was hugely positive and constructive.  A robust action plan will be put in place with some small tests of change run ASAP to test their efficacy before 'winter' begins.  It was great that the emphasis was on finding the best solutions for patients and the wider system and not on blame.  Some fantastic collaborative work which can only bode well for the Futures programme in our system.
 
And as promised a bonus Summer blog from DRSS…
It’s a very busy time at DRSS.  Not only are we changing all of our processes so that we have a single way of working across both of our sites in Newton Abbot and Plymouth, and getting a new patient (PAS) system; we are also developing a new database system to feed all the reporting and monitoring requirements of the service.  On top of this we also have all 3 of our major national IT systems being replaced: NHSnet – the NHS Spine, NHSmail and Choose and Book (to be known as e-Referrals), in addition to a new CCG wide IT system, DELT, and a new outsourcing contract for all patient letters – all in the next 5 months!

Whilst all this is going on we will still support approximately 6,000 people per week with their physical and mental health referrals. These come from a range of sources including GPs, opticians, dentists and extended scope practitioners (physiotherapists and podiatrists).

We will also be working hard to support the CCG with their plans for financial recovery as part of the NHS Futures programme, particularly focusing on the demand management.

Never heard of us?  Who we are and why we exist…
Devon Referral Support Services (DRSS) is a referrals contact centre which supports individuals in getting the right advice, care or treatment in a timely manner, and we are very passionate about this!  We can’t do this work alone though and work closely with a wide range of people, groups and organisations within our local communities, and further afield, to build collaborative, sustainable systems and solutions within the context of local CCG priorities.

We also provide a range of services that complement and support the contact centre:
  • facilitation of service and commissioning redesign across Devon to address financial recovery (such as demand management). 
  • managing localised pages of the National Directory of Services (DoS) to ensure the database reflects current service provision in Devon, Cornwall and Isle of Scilly.
  • managing 18 community clinics, and booking the physiotherapy service in  South Devon.
DRSS are part of the Collaborative Business Service arm of NEW Devon CCG and provide services for a number of organisations including the 3 local CCGs, NHS England and Devon Partnership Trust for a population of 1.3 million people. 

DRSS Highlights of the week 1 -  Improving the recruitment process
Nearly 10% of the CCG workforce is either a current or former apprentice and earlier this year the CCG was recognised as being Apprentice Employer of the Year by ETS.  

Since 2010 DRSS have employed nearly 60 apprentices (45% of our workforce). We’re really proud that 44 of these apprentices are still working with us in some capacity and that most of the others still work in the local NHS. Working with ETS to develop an apprenticeship programme tailored to the requirements of a business admin role within a NHS referral contact centre has been a fantastic way to ensure that all their learning is relevant, topical and supportive.  

With so many of our team joining us through apprenticeships it has been important to get the recruitment part right, so we’ve been recently asking candidates, both successful and unsuccessful, for their thoughts on our process and have used this feedback to make some changes.

This is the first interview for some candidates so the ‘traditional’ process of a face to face interview doesn’t really give them the best opportunity to shine and share their potential.  How many times have people stormed the interview process but failed to live up to expectations, or frustrated us by being extremely capable of doing a job but being so nervous that they really don’t interview well at all?

To try and get a rounder picture of candidates (and for candidates to get a rounder picture of DRSS as a potential employer) we have now introduced an icebreaker session which the interviewers join in with, a group exercise, a telephone test, a letter test and a chance to meet current apprentices and chat to them informally.

This may all sound rather daunting, but we’ve now used this in 3 rounds of interviews, the latest last week, and feedback has been great.  The candidates felt they had a good understanding of what the job entailed, and we had more time to spend with everyone to get a better sense of their strengths, values and interpersonal skills, which may not be picked up during the ordinary interview. 

Our current apprentices have also really appreciated the opportunity to give something back and chat to new potential staff members.

DRSS Highlight of the week 2  -  Communication creativity
Communication is always a tricky thing.  No matter what we seem to do people don’t feel that they know what’s going on.  Sometimes we can feel that we repeat ourselves (and bore people) endlessly and yet people still don’t think they know what’s going on.

One area we’ve been thinking a lot about is how we communicate with GP practices. We have a bi-monthly bulletin (monthly if there’s a lot going on) which sometimes feels like it’s full of provider information.  It doesn’t always fulfil its potential to share information about our service and yet we have so much information to share.

This edition feels like we might have turned a creative corner!  In fact, we’re really rather proud of it and are feeling energised by providing something we feel is useful.  It’s available here so have a look and see what you think! (You’ll need access to NHSnet to see it though).

DRSS Highlight of the week 3 -  The impact of health literacy
Dealing with six thousand referrals per week means that we are in contact with a whole range of people, with a whole range of needs.  Equality and Diversity are part and parcel of our work so we were thrilled to meet with the CCG Leads for Learning Disabilities for some really helpful discussions about how 'health literacy' issues can limit access to healthcare due to impaired comprehension, difficulties in communicating, lack of assertiveness and their dependency on carers.

We are really looking forward to working with the team to see how we can better support people with LDs or dementias by reviewing our letters, phone scripts and patient surveys to ensure they are ‘Easy Read’.  
We know it’s going to take a work of art to get our patient letter right for everybody (we’ve already had conversations with our practice manager group on how to do this) but we are up for the challenge!

DRSS Highlight of the week 4 -  Welcoming more primary care practitioners to the team
As a clinically led service we have a team of practicing GPs from across Devon and East Cornwall who, with their clinical knowledge, provide general advice and support to the team.  They are pivotal to supporting the implementation of commissioning policies, clinical referral guidelines (aka pathways) and potential upgrades to urgent or 2ww priorities.

This week we have appointed 6 new GPs to join the team to help ensure we have clinical cover each day, especially over the holiday periods.  

We have found that the GP role is a vital link between practices and providers, building rapport and relationships that inform and shape how the service develops and so we are pleased to welcome some new faces and new energy to the team J.

DRSS Highlight of the week 5 – Take a little time to be kind
Kindness – although we’re all the centre of our own universes not everything is about us as individuals.  Taking minute can have the most profound impact on people and as a contact centre we have dealings with thousands of people each week, all with their own stories.  

This week we booked an appointment for an 84 year old gentleman.  He asked if he could take a further minute to play a song on his cello.  He had been a member of an orchestra and didn’t get to play for people anymore.  The call was put on speakerphone and he played ‘The Swan’ to the team.  Having someone to play to again made him very happy and brightened the team’s day too.

Another, rather distressed, patient called to find out information about his referral for a suspected cancer.  He’d been around the houses a bit, and although his referral hadn’t come through the referral service just the fact that someone investigated for him reassured him that he could carry on his day as normal.  The consultant responded within the hour giving him an appointment and peace of mind that he hadn’t been ‘lost in the system’.

Knowing that taking just a minute of our time, no matter how busy we are, can make such a difference to people is a real bonus to us and can be rewarding for everyone.  In the words of Aesop:
‘No act of kindness, no matter how small, is ever wasted’.

Friday, 1 August 2014

Highlights of the Week - 1st August 2014

Last week at work before the holiday and full of the usual charging round to get things completed before going on leave; a whirlwind of activity both at work and at home before being able to settle back and enjoy the break.  

This year I've taken on to try and change our broadband and phone supplier this week too.  They have put their prices up so we have an opportunity to cancel the long-term contract without penalty.  We have had problems with the super fast technology and crackly phone over the last six months.  It isn't the provider's fault, engineers from BT have described the state of the wiring in the box at the bottom of the road as dreadful and the repeated issues track back to there.

But, each time I have rung to report a fault or that a repair hasn't worked, I'm faced with the same message "We're sorry, but we have an unexpectedly high level of customer calls today and the time to speak to a consultant will be around 30 minutes".  The actual 30 minute wait could  be up to 50 minutes, meaning that calls could be over an hour... and I've probably made 8 of those over the last few months.

The bit that really annoys me is the message; if on a given day calls peak unexpectedly, then I could understand, but seeking to blame me, the customer, because there simply aren't enough staff on duty to deal with calls on every time I've called is hugely frustrating and has definitely contributed to the slightly more angst ridden interactions with the company than I might usually try and exhibit.  

So their time has come, but is that really the top priority for this week.......?

Highlights of the Week - 1st August 2014 (@jeclo)

Highlights of the Week 1: Feedback about the team has been great this week; lots of areas where their contribution has been recognised
It is easy to go unnoticed in commissioning; it is not the most glamorous part of the NHS and you are not surrounded by patients thanking you for your care.  But there is plenty of commitment and passion in the work that the team does and over the last week there have been a number of times when people have paused to comment on the performance of both the clinical and managerial leaders.

We are making good progress, whether in resilience planning, integration, changes in planned care, our recovery plan or in the structure we are putting around our programmes and projects and the people who are working on all of those have been the subject of positive comment - some in passing, some for small elements and some recognising a sustained piece of leadership. Very enjoyable listening!

Highlights of the Week 2: Members of the Governing Body observing the Western Locality Board and the feedback is very positive
We had a smaller than usual Locality Board this week, given holidays and other absences, but nevertheless there was a full agenda with plenty to discuss from our plans for Integration, procurement of community services and the high risk issues around quality of care.

The Board does pay significant attention to the range of quality and performance indicators that we are struggling to meet and consider whether the actions in place are sufficient to move us towards recovery.  This month issues include A&E performance, Stroke services, referral to treatment times and timeliness of communication.  

The focus isn't about the target itself, it is about the impact on the patients who haven't been seen within the required timescale; the key question will be about whether we understand the risk to that cohort.  Those are the issues we track in our Integrated Provider Assurance Meetings and good to see this week that our attention is recognised by the Governing Body who observed our meeting.

Highlights of the Week 3: We launch "NHS Futures-Transforming care in Devon and Plymouth" and have a clear plan for the next steps
The CCG is taking over the programme management role for the joint programme of work across health and social care organisations in Devon and Plymouth to move the system towards sustainability from PWC who have been supporting the Financially Challenged Health Economy work.

The next 2 years will see us work on the "NHS Futures" programme with streams of work led by Chief Executives looking at areas such as planned care, urgent care and specialist commissioning.  We have a set of meetings now leading towards the first Programme Board meeting in late September.  By that date we will have agreed leadership roles, project teams, key milestones and scope.

Hopefully this will see us enter a really productivity phase of activity across the community that will significantly shift the level of agreement and alignment around system vision.

Highlights of the Week 4: An emergency measures meeting; many have been here before us, but good energy and ideas
I have worked in several financially challenged areas, turnaround environments or other financial recovery modes and there is a pattern to how a year plays out.

There will be a very clear sense at plan stage that the numbers don't quite work and there ends with some optimistic assumptions, best case delivery schemes or simply an unresolved gap.  At this stage the organisation will have spent a lot of time thinking about  every possible action they could take to produce a more robust plan.

But notwithstanding that work at different points during the year the organisation will be required to improve and revisit plans with "escalated" or "emergency" measures.

We are at that place now: the unaddressed risk in the CCG is rising and we need to take further action if we are to hit our agreed, planned deficit of £14.7 million.

The team worked hard this week on the range of emergency actions we could take.  As ever, we have tried to create an environment that stimulates new ideas and we did produce a new set of actions to take forward. We continue to consider elements that will impact on the range of services that we are able to commission as well as efficiency or internal measures.

It is not the most enjoyable work; the highlight is about the commitment and energy that was brought to the task.

Highlights of the Week 5: There are guest bloggers for the next 2 weeks: off on holiday leaving things in good hands
In case you haven't picked it up, I'm off on holiday for two weeks!

There will be guest bloggers filling this space next week and my thanks to Sharon Williams, who will offer highlights as the Head of our Planning and Programme Office, Sharon Matson as Head of Commissioning in the Western Locality and Rachael Burridge who will be sharing 5 extra highlights (so there will be a huge 10 next week) about our referral management service.

Enjoy that; I know I will....!



You can read other blogs related to the work of the Western Locality of NEW Devon CCG
About our workplan: Western Locality Workplan
About our Locality business: Western Locality Business

Jerry Clough is Chief Operating Officer for Northern, Eastern and Western Devon Clinical Commissioning Group.  He is also Locality Managing Director for the Western Locality of the CCG covering Plymouth and the surrounding areas of South Hams and West Devon.

Previously Jerry has been a Chief Executive and Finance Director in the NHS before spending several years running his own business driving programmes of change and delivering executive coaching and team and Board development.



Sunday, 27 July 2014

Highlights of the Week - 25th July 2014

The summer holidays have started, the schools are out and it has been welcomed in many parts, but particularly in Devon, with a week of wall-to-wall sunshine.  

We will have visitors from all over - York, Cumbria, Malawi - and, other than when we are away, they will be with us each week through to September.  It is great to welcome people to to the South West and to show them some of the beautiful country around.  This week, given the weather, that has been a selection of beaches for our guests.

Not that I've been making those trips; my week has been hot and sticky in different meeting rooms, trying to concentrate as the temperature soars.  One particular venue we use has a conference room above the swimming pool complex of a holiday park.  The room is really good value, but it does mean that some of time is spent listening or watching kids cooling off outside, which can be off-putting!

I have been out in the early morning sun with the dog, so there is no complaint about the weather or indeed the knowledge that the rest of my family are on holiday.  But it is hard, even when there are more than 5 great highlights each week, not to feel at least a bit of a pang when I get a text in the middle of a workshop saying "I'm swimming in the sea - glorious".  What's the text back?

Highlights of the Week - 25th July 2014 (@jeclo)

Highlights of the Week 1: An interview that shows we are on the right track with development and direction
Sometimes interviewing is really enjoyable.  It was this week.  We interviewed for a post in the Programme Office and the successful candidate, who already works in that team, performed excellently.

We have worked really hard on helping the Programme Office to get a sense of clear identity and purpose and not to feel like they are at the beck and call of the rest of the CCG. The interview centred on questions around the role of the team both in financial recovery within the CCG and with the work of our "NHS Futures" programme that follows on from the 11 week intensive programme under the Financially Challenged Health Economy banner.

So a great moment to reflect on our journey of development as an organisation, noticing the small steps of encouragement amongst the huge challenges, but more importantly, fantastic for the individual and their growth and development in the role.

Highlights of the Week 2: Planned Care Summit-looking at all the options we have to make the system affordable and sustainable
We have held two summits within the CCG this week and the first of those was on planned care. There is a wisdom that you would want a system that invests well in planned care and therefore spends less on urgent care because this would be an indication that disease is well managed.  To some degree, that is what our system looks like, though the reality is that we spend too much in total, compared to our allocation and our job is to make the position sustainable.

Lots of clinicians in the room for the discussion and really encouraging to see the contribution from our lead GPs from across the different areas of the CCG.  We discussed the challenge and looked at how we might move forward with a long-term strategy within the NHS Futures programme-all organisations in the health and social care system working towards common goals.

The focus was also on the immediate and the short term and the difficult actions we need to take in order to deliver our financial position this year. Those discussions are not easy, but we do recognise our responsibility and there was good attention to the task.

There are many balances here, for example, the need to press ahead to achieve referral to treatment targets, but we did confirm a number of actions that we will press forward with and talk to providers about over the next few weeks.

Highlights of the Week 3: The new CCG Executive meeting makes time for strategy, operational delivery and assurance
We have had reviews of governance within the CCG-it is an inevitable consequence of being in deficit as people want to check that the position isn't driven by poor management processes, but it is also part of our desire to review, learn and improve.

The CCG Executive has replaced the Leadership Team meeting in the CCG and binds the clinicians from across all localities far more closely in to the key discussions that affect the whole of the organisation.

This week, the agenda invited us to work to three different tasks: 
  • Strategy-ensuring that we are managing our 9 programmes of strategic change in the organisation that link to the NHS Futures programme.  This week we reviewed the initiation documents, checked scope and confirmed purpose to ensure we are aligned to take this work forward with partners
  • Operational delivery-monitoring the in-year financial position and reviewing the workplan tracker that shows where we are with the delivery of the projects that aim to give the right level of commissioner savings
  • Assurance-a review of the different aspects of the CCG and making sure that all members are aware of the governance, risk, patient safety & quality or performance issues that are the most important for us to be monitoring.
Not a perfect meeting - how many are? - but definitely a step in the right direction and with an even greater focus on action orientation we will get to a really effective engine for the CCG.

Highlights of the Week 4: Continuing Health Care Summit-a difficult challenge to manage our growth, but it is all of our responsibility 
We've seen significant growth in our CHC spend over the last few years. In keeping with many other CCGs, especially those around us, there have been rises of 9%, 9% and 20% over the last few years, without the impact of retrospective claims.  We are one of the highest spending CCGs in the country (in the top 20 for both number of cases and cost) and are also high in the South West, which does see some of the bigger numbers nationally.

It is a hard budget to manage.  We make the payments, but the assessments are nationally described and carried out by our local providers, so it can feel like we are simply the banker to the system.  We clearly are closely involved, we run high cost panels and work to ensure that the system is operating effectively and in the way we expect it to.

The task at the Summit was to get a group of people together, with clear clinical leadership, to take a fresh look.  What more could we be doing this year?  What is our strategy and how could the system be different in years to come?  In essence, to move from a situation where we pay the bills that arrive to one that feels like we have a system that we have commissioned.

We didn't solve all of the issues in one go, but we certainly made progress, we rigorously tested our current thinking and assumptions and came up with some new ideas and actions.

Highlights of the Week 5: Lots of 5 minute conversations that keep things moving in the right direction
When I get in the car in the mornings, there is a moment when I have to concentrate hard to remember which direction I'm heading off in first; right will take me off towards our base in Plymouth, left to Exeter, workshops or further afield.  Increasingly that changes day to day as the Chief Operating Officer role requires me to work across the whole CCG. I think it is true for all in the Leadership team too, as we need collective strategy and delivery more than ever now.

So increasingly it is the 5 minute telephone calls or quick emails that I need to rely on, rather than being physically present and this week has been a particular test of what can be achieved through brief interaction with a number of things to co-ordinate, a diary that needed to change each day and an impending holiday meaning that things must be completed by next Friday.

But it has felt purposeful.  I have got used to coaching on the phone and via FaceTime or Skype, having initially resisted as I like to be sat face-to-face with someone for those kind of sessions.  All it does take is concentration and not trying to replace a meeting where I concentrate with a quick conversation when I'm trying to buy a sandwich for lunch. 


One more week to a holiday.  I'll have highlights next week, but then will be offline.  I'm looking for a guest from within the CCG to share their highlights here for two weeks.  Let's see who reads to this point and takes up that offer!


You can read other blogs related to the work of the Western Locality of NEW Devon CCG
About our workplan: Western Locality Workplan
About our Locality business: Western Locality Business

Jerry Clough is Chief Operating Officer for Northern, Eastern and Western Devon Clinical Commissioning Group.  He is also Locality Managing Director for the Western Locality of the CCG covering Plymouth and the surrounding areas of South Hams and West Devon.

Previously Jerry has been a Chief Executive and Finance Director in the NHS before spending several years running his own business driving programmes of change and delivering executive coaching and team and Board development.




Saturday, 19 July 2014

Highlights of the Week - 18th July 2014

Today our eldest heads off for a month long-long trip to Tanzania.  It is an educational and charitable expedition where she will work for 3 weeks on various projects ending with some relaxation to finish.

It has been a long time coming as she has spent the last 18 months gathering the money to go through a range of different fund raising activities - santa fun runs, cake sales, car boot sales, sponsored events and babysitting to name a few.

The rest of the family are off on our summer holidays for a couple of weeks while she is away and, with different people visiting us in Devon, there was only one window to fit that in.  Somewhere in my careful and precise planning I have managed to lose the exact calculation so I have recently had to explain to both my daughter and wife that, following  being away for 4 weeks and an exhausting journey, our 15 year old will arrive home almost a full day before we do....

All is sorted and she will be collected and well looked after by the neighbours, but it has led to a barrage of sarcasm and humour amongst friends and relatives.  Despite preferences for looking at the big picture, I'm usually very good at attending to detail when I need to, so not quite sure how this has happened. 

But there is no use crying over split milk; learn and move on - which, for today, will mostly be about dealing with the excitement and no doubt a few tears as she jets off on her amazing adventure.

Highlights of the Week - 18th July 2014 (@jeclo)

Highlights of the Week 1: Better Care Fund is confusing, but great energy to use it as a lever on our integration journey
We held a workshop on Monday within the CCG to collect together where we are with 2 Better Care Funds (Devon and Plymouth) and to be clear about our overarching narrative and next steps.

It is a moving target - new guidance, a new programme approach at the Centre and all the political chatter about the wisdom of the policy and its deliverability.  I have described here before how it is really hard to see from a local perspective how you move blocks of money around successfully from hospital care to social and community services under payment by results rules, especially where hospitals are running at high levels of occupancy.

It is not defeatist - I do think we can invest to find ways to offer different models that keep more people safe, well and at home - but it is a need for realism when we look at the best way to progress in a challenged financial environment.

The workshop was really positive though, linking back our work on BCF with our overarching 5 year strategy and particularly our journey towards integration with both local authorities. More conversations now with Council colleagues about plans and to make sure we spend more time talking to all providers about how we change the urgent care systems.  This needs to be a key element of our wider work on system affordability.


Highlights of the Week 2: Talking to Ben Gowland at Nene CCG about the shared challenges in different places: helpful and encouraging
Some of the benefit of attending the NHS Confederation annual conference is about the connections, networking and links that can be made there. This week I spoke to Ben Gowland, Chief Officer at Nene Clinical Commissioning Group, following an introduction made through a mutual contact at the conference.

Nene, like NEW Devon, are a financial challenged health economy, so the discussion was centred on how our respective joint work is progressing. The layout and landscape is different, but the issues are the same and it was incredibly helpful to hear about their journey, how they had overcome some of the challenges we are facing and for both of us to reflect on the fact that there are other areas where the pressures and issues feel similar.

We discussed Programme Directors, programme management arrangements, the role of national bodies - NHS England, Monitor and the NHS Trust Development Authority - and the role of commissioning in system recovery.  Most of all though, we talked about the need to create and maintain positive relationships with all local stakeholders and to keep everyone aligned around the shared vision.


Highlights of the Week 3: Chief Officer Leadership Group takes some steps forward. Hard, but a complex joint programme won't be easy
A week on and the work on the Financially Challenged Health Economy in Devon and Plymouth takes another step forward.  Some steps seem smaller than others and this week felt a bit like we were repeating some discussions that we have had previously.  But keeping everyone on the same page is vital and we did make real progress with finalising different elements of the programme architecture.

This week we got agreement for all Chief Executives in the room to sponsor key programmes of work.  By the next time we sit down, we will have a fully populated and completed programme and will be able to begin the delivery phase.  There was undoubtedly frustration at how long some processes are taking and we do need to reflect on how to push forward with greater pace, but there are 15 organisations involved and it is important that we keep all of them together with a shared purpose.


Highlights of the Week 4: Response to a performance challenge steals too much time, but the team produces real quality
Nationally there has been a dip in performance around the 2 week-wait breast cancer target and we have two trusts within NEW Devon that have had particular performance challenges. It was the subject of discussion at our Governing Body this week and there was both clear concern and a requirement to see action to improve.

The Trusts have seen an increase in demand, perhaps due in part to national awareness campaigns and a storyline in Eastenders and have not been able to flex capacity to deal with the additional activity.

We have felt as a commissioner that we have tracked this issue and dealt appropriately with the response of the Trusts.  It is clearly not the outcome we want - achieving key performance targets is important - but we have held good discussions about prioritising scarce resources to those in most clinical need, even if this means that other targets struggle.

However, when something gets to a national level, the demand for explanation and information can become intense and require a huge amount of staff time and energy to respond to. This can be one of the most dispiriting parts of he job, but the team responded really well this week and by the end it feels like we have produced a really high quality set of information and used the time to recheck the robustness of our plans and the provider plans and improve them.

We don't want to get in to crisis response mode too often; it is useful to know that when we do, though, the response will be the right one.

Highlights of the Week 5: If we keep talking, we'll find a consensus way forward: conversations about community services 
There is a theme this week about conversations and communication.  We are aiming to move forward with large parts of the reprocurement of community services in Plymouth and Devon without the need for competitive procurement due to a focus on integration. The responses to our consultation on this were mixed from our local provider community where we had hoped for greater consensus.  

However, this week we have had a number of conversations with a range of organisations involved and everyone still seems to want to get to a solution that will work for all. From a position that felt really challenging for our ambition, our sense is now that, whilst we have had a wide number of stakeholder and provider engagement events throughout the last 12 months, what may help to move forward is a range of discussions with groups of providers in each community. 

And the plea has been to allow people to work through the next level of detail.  Nobody has argued with the key direction of our community strategy, in fact almost all responses have started with their organisations agreement with our vision, but there are some things that will only make sense when we work through how it will actually work in practice.


So ... you live and learn.  Perhaps there is more attention to detail that would help not only my daughter to feel welcomed back home after being away for 4 times longer than ever before, but also help translate strategy in to concrete reality for colleagues at work!

Anyway, anyone want to look after our dog whilst we are away......


You can read other blogs related to the work of the Western Locality of NEW Devon CCG
About our workplan: Western Locality Workplan
About our Locality business: Western Locality Business

Jerry Clough is Chief Operating Officer for Northern, Eastern and Western Devon Clinical Commissioning Group.  He is also Locality Managing Director for the Western Locality of the CCG covering Plymouth and the surrounding areas of South Hams and West Devon.

Previously Jerry has been a Chief Executive and Finance Director in the NHS before spending several years running his own business driving programmes of change and delivering executive coaching and team and Board development.

Saturday, 12 July 2014

Highlights of the Week - 11th July 2014

This week we have started the planning process for 2015/16 in earnest.  It will be a complex year as the process around our commissioning intentions will need to seamlessly fit together with the joint programme of work that will follow from the Financially Challenged Local Health Economy work;  this is moving in to the second phase where we need to turn our global intentions in to substantive plans.  In order to get that right, we need to start earlier and really clearly map out for all our stakeholders how the different elements support each other.

The irony of starting looking at next year is that we are both still finalising the fine points of some of the contracts for this year and are in the middle of significant operational pressures that require complete focus on the quality and financial aspects of the current year's performance.

It all feels increasingly like, whether in the hospital where emergency activity growth is making the environment feel like winter pressures in the summer or in the commissioning organisation, there is not going to be the usual slightly quieter period that exists after completing one contracting round and before the winter pressures kick in.

And what happens when there is no space in a system to recover and regroup? I think it is a real concern for the NHS in all aspects of the current work burden.  Whilst we can see the impact of financial overspends or treatment pressures, I'm not so sure we are sighted on what the long-term impact will be of the level of pressure that staff are now being expected to work under.

Time then for some....

Highlights of the Week - 11th July 2014 (@jeclo)

Highlights of the Week 1: Drawing up the outline of our Primary Care Programme points to the huge opportunities for improving care
We've been finalising the key strategic programmes of work for the next couple of years, one of which is the co-commissioning of primary care, so this week I spent some time discussing the different elements and projects that constitute this programme; essentially mapping the process by which we move from an outline strategy to having a detailed workplan for the development of primary care.

One of the five pillars that make up our 5-year strategy is about general practice, working at scale being the organising unit of care.  This is a really exciting proposition - federated groups or merged general practices being large enough for community health and social care services to map on to the practice population and create a 1:1 relationship.  The opportunities that would create across a whole range of urgent and planned care are huge and something that I really believe we should be paying more attention to nationally.

The programme looks at benefits beyond that too for both general practices as commissioners and as providers.  The wider primary care market creates even more options, though we are not looking to commission these in the first instance, taking an incremental approach.  We will make sure that we join things up though and so the possibilities around pharmacy, for example, will be a key part of the programme of work.

Highlights of the Week 2: The Big Listen-Feedback from our staff is really encouraging about how the Locality and CCG is starting to mature
We had the third of our "Big" events this week, where we get together with a group of staff who either work in the Western Locality or support our work to explore how well things are working.  We have now run these on a six monthly basis over the last 18 months and this time had around 50 members of staff.  Interestingly, showing how our direction of travel is moving, this time there were 6 members of local authority staff who had taken up the opportunity to attend .

We talked about integration and our key workplan for the year to make sure everyone understands the key focus for the locality and CCG.  Most importantly, though, we gave people time to reflect on things and provide feedback on those key areas.

The core of the event is the "Big Listen" a space where the Leadership Team in the Locality are invited to listen to feedback (without interruption, comment or justification) from the members of staff present.  It has taken some practice to get to a point where the listening environment is created and staff feel able to openly share, but we are definitely moving in the right direction and the benefits are clear.

We got feedback this week that staff feel things are generally improving and some of the systems and processes in the CCG are starting to mature and feel more secure. Clearly some of that is about the issues themselves; some, I am sure, is because our determination to listen and to feedback ("You said, we did") demonstrates it is worthwhile.

Highlights of the Week 3: The presence of Local Authorities at our away day looks right and the presentation is really joined up
The second of three highlights from the development day is the joint presentation that was given about integration with Devon County and Plymouth City Councils by a joint team from the CCG and Local Authority.  We are working hard with both Councils on the integration agenda - both of service delivery and of commissioning - so there is a lot to say, especially at this moment with Plymouth City Council as we have reached the point of agreeing a joint business case setting objectives for March 2015 and 2016.

The feedback from staff noted how impressed they were about the seamless join between the organisations presenting and the obvious work that has gone on over the last weeks and months to get to a point where the messages are the same from either party.

There are huge challenges ahead with lots of discussions about governance, accountability and money to resolve before we get to move towards the level and scale of integration that we envisage, but this week was another sign that we have got many things right.

Highlights of the Week 4: We've asked a lot of staff through changes over the last 2 years, but they are still up for integrating commissioning
And the final away-day highlight was the reaction of our staff to the presentation on integration.  The vast majority of the Locality and CCG are made up of staff who went through the transition from PCTs, Clusters, networks and Strategic Health Authorities to end up working in NEW Devon.  This means that it is only about 18 months since they were last applying for jobs, being interviewed and coping with all the anxieties that this involved.

That change process was long and protracted, so there was an extended period of worrying about futures, salaries and being employed that they had to cope with.  This week, we discussed moving towards integrated commissioning and the kind of options we are considering.  Everyone understands what this means - eventually some and potentially all health and social care staff within the scope of the programme of integrated commissioning may move to a new organisation through some, as yet undetermined change process.  We can't yet say 'who' and we don't yet know 'to where', but we did discuss the sense of change.

Clearly staff were concerned, but given a couple of hours to think, discuss and reflect, the overriding response was that integrating makes clear sense and that we should be pursuing that line if we are to deliver on our vision to make the biggest impact for patients most efficiently.  Lots of feedback and pleas to ensure we manage our HR processes with a greater sense of understanding of the impact on individuals, but an acknowledgement of the need to progress; hugely encouraging.

Highlights of the Week 5: The Governing Body is carefully considered the responses to our community services consultation; the purpose is clear
We have finished an 8 week consultation on our community services strategy and our preferred option for procurement.  We have attracted significant attention as we are looking at a non-competitive award of contract for some significant elements of service in order to maximise the benefits of service integration.

The feedback this week was, as expected, mixed with a range of different opinions on the proposed way forward.  Faced with this broad range, the Governing Body has an important decision to take about the next steps leading up to key meeting in October when final options need to be determined to achieve the required timeline.

The discussion this week and listening carefully to the detailed views that have been expressed was very positive for the Governing Body balancing the different perspectives with a reminder of the purpose of the reprocurement.  There are no easy solutions and no risk free options; it is all about balance and judgement.  It does, however, feel like we are listening hard, considering carefully and do understand the importance of the next steps. This is another intense process with few gaps with staff who have been working flat out for many months; we also are thinking about how we support them.

And in terms of the long-haul, on the upside, after a very long, sometimes exciting, but too often painful, period of heightened watchfulness has been brought to an end.  Whilst I'll miss the fantastic talent, overall my total fatigue with the situation means that I'm relieved that we can now move forward.  On this issue at least, I can now rest.  Goodbye Luis Suarez, good luck in Barcelona, thanks for the memories.  Now relax.....


You can read other blogs related to the work of the Western Locality of NEW Devon CCG
About our workplan: Western Locality Workplan
About our Locality business: Western Locality Business

Jerry Clough is Chief Operating Officer for Northern, Eastern and Western Devon Clinical Commissioning Group.  He is also Locality Managing Director for the Western Locality of the CCG covering Plymouth and the surrounding areas of South Hams and West Devon.

Previously Jerry has been a Chief Executive and Finance Director in the NHS before spending several years running his own business driving programmes of change and delivering executive coaching and team and Board development.

Friday, 4 July 2014

Highlights of the Week - 4th July 2014

It was the youngest's birthday this week. Lots of sports equipment requested: obligatory new pair of football boots, (which have featured on every list over the last 5 years of birthdays and Christmases) and, as a new entry, cricket kit - bat, gloves, pads, bag, ball etc.

As usual a wonderful reaction to the various presents that did arrive, some identical to the list, others similar to what was asked for (he is very specific on brand and model) and some that he simply didn't get, which was all fine.

He contemplated his new bat for a while, making all the right noises, but something was not right.  Eventually, in tears, he declared that he didn't like Kookaburra bats, but he felt terrible for being so selfish for saying so. ("Its fine, we can change it...")

This reminded me of a great piece of learning about presents.  We tend to give presents from our perspective (we give what we'd like to receive) and receive from the other person's perspective (we say what we think they would want to hear). How much better would be the world if we were truly able to give what the other person really wanted and valued and receive gifts in a way that was true to what we feel (with respect for the gift and the giver, but truth about our reaction)?

So we discussed "selfish" and "ungrateful" and the need to respect the effort, generosity and thought that goes in to the buying of presents, but the benefit of being true to self and carefully explaining what we like and don't like. He does often wish, I suspect, that his dad would just let him be!


Highlights of the Week 4th July 2014 (@jeclo)

Highlights of the Week 1: NEW Devon CCG has a new Chief Nursing Officer.  I'd congratulate Lorna Collingwood-Burke if she was on Twitter!
Really delighted that Lorna has come through a tough recruitment process with a significant field to be appointed as the new Chief Nursing Officer for the CCG.  I have worked with Lorna over the last couple of years and she undoubtedly has the values, experience, leadership and relationships to take forward the role.

Of course, with a new role comes new responsibilities and I'm looking forward to Lorna joining the small number of the Senior Leadership Team in the CCG who regularly use social media to share some of our key messages.  So, I'm not sure, without use of Twitter, whether Lorna will ever get to this blog (there are links in my email signature block and in our weekly staff bulletin, so perhaps), but if she does.....  make one of your first actions getting a presence on Twitter and then make a commitment to a regular tweet or two to highlight the great work that you and your team do!


Highlights of the Week 2: There are now three blogs in the Western Locality: you can find out about our workplan and Locality business too
I have been trying to enthuse the team for some time that we need to get a different approach to our communication and test out a new way for the CCG to engage with both our own staff, partners and anyone else who might be interested.

This week we have launched two new blogs, one on our Locality Workplan that Nicola Jones is in the hot seat for and the other on detailing the Locality business, including the parish notices, that Debbie Whiting will co-ordinate.  

Some of this content won't be particularly relevant or perhaps even interesting to people outside of the organisation, but much of it will and I think writing the communication in a blog form and in a way that we are happy to share publicly will change our approach. 

So here they are








Highlights of the Week 3 : Launch of Individuals at the Centre Year 2.  How will it support the delivery of our financial transformation?
Really delighted to be working with Tim Robson from nowshopup.com (@timrobson07) again this week to launch the second year of our Individuals at the Centre Programme.

Our key aims are:
  • to get the half day workshop to over 90% of our staff
  • to have 15 project teams working through a modular programme with as much energy and passion as the 5 teams in year 1
  • to deliver at the same cost and fractional cost per participant by moving to a lot of online, nudge and self directed content, supported by a social media platform
  • to go further beyond the CCG to work with partners, regionally and nationally
So we have set challenging goals.

The Leadership Team will all mentor projects this year and this will ensure a greater sense of organisation wide effort.

Of course, everything in the CCG needs to be firmly aligned to our financial recovery and transformation programmes.  So how do you reconcile this kind of bottom up change with the absolutely relentless focus on a CCG wide requirement?

We are expecting the teams when they volunteer to apply for the programme to have worked that out.  We want to get lots of applications that address the financial issue head on; if they don't, they probably won't get supported (improving quality in an austerity climate is clearly part of this).  What we want to test though, is that the finance message is so well understood and owned that our staff will make that link for themselves, without having to add it as an application criteria.

We'll wait and see!  But lots of energy from the whole leadership team to address the challenges and support staff to do that from themselves as well as follow our clear direction. And wonderful reflections on year one from participants, mentors and those who watched the showcase.

Highlights of the Week 4 : Integration discussions with both Plymouth City and Devon County Councils making great progress
The CCG straddles two local authorities: the unitary authority in Plymouth and Devon County Council.  These Councils move at different speeds, given their size and unitary versus two tier structure.

In to the mix of integration and the Better Care Fund we also have our plans for the reprocurement of community services that we need to complete before contracts expire in 2015 and 2016.  All in all, this makes the life of integration and our CCG complicated.

That we are making great progress with both local authorities is, therefore, a real testament to the quality of relationships we are building with key councillors and officers and for their and our resolve that the path we are set is incredibly important and is worth the energy.

This week we were at Caring Plymouth Scrutiny Committee for a review of the business cases we have with the City Council for integrated commissioning and integrated delivery of services.  There were plenty of questions and we pointed to a huge range of issues that we have yet to resolve, but we are making really significant progress and the Committee noted the alignment we are demonstrating.

The discussion with Devon County Council allowed us to step back and review the ambition of our joint vision and then how this would play out through our community services decisions.  It was heartening that we both acknowledged the importance of continuing to find time to ask "why" - to be clear on the core purpose of integrating services and commissioning - rather than keeping pressing on with lots of urgent tasks. We reconfirmed our joint intent and the next actions that would move us forward.

Highlights of the Week 5 : The workshop "How to live with zero:Why I choose to have so many emails in my inbox" finally happened this week
It has been trailed here and throughout the organisation and finally I managed to deliver the first of the two hour workshops that I'll be running with staff from across the CCG that invites them to pause and think about how they manage their inboxes.

The reason is that most people find this a source of real stress and anxiety; a sense that the world is bombarding them and they are not in control.  I've coached a lot of people on that stress over the last few years and the workshop is a combination of that work and my personal journey to get to a point where I live with zero emails in my inbox and have done for quite a few years.

So as more electronic letters were trickling in to our systems, about 20 people attended the workshop and listened, participated, discussed and reviewed the key messages.  The feedback has been great (someone today told me that they already have 300 fewer emails in their inbox) and I'll be doing it again in other locations across the CCG.

The biggest message of all is that your inbox is a result of your choices... it doesn't land easily for people, but after a while people do reflect on how they prioritise different tasks at work and how that impacts on the number of items left to process.


And of course, within 24 hours, our youngest had decided he loved his new bat and was telling me all about the great things about it.  Given time to reflect and little pressure, he formed his own conclusion, which was a great result.  It has scored its first runs and that makes him very happy! Let's hope he has as much fun with it as I had with my Duncan Fearnley, Ian Botham Attack (you never forget your first bat) when I was his age....



Jerry Clough is Chief Operating Officer for Northern, Eastern and Western Devon Clinical Commissioning Group.  He is also Locality Managing Director for the Western Locality of the CCG covering Plymouth and the surrounding areas of South Hams and West Devon.

Previously Jerry has been a Chief Executive and Finance Director in the NHS before spending several years running his own business driving programmes of change and delivering executive coaching and team and Board development.